Kokomo Tribune; Kokomo, Indiana


February 18, 2013

HEINIG: Is Indiana’s new governor a new Old Deluder?

Giving families ‘school choice’ only ignores the problem

— Is Gov. Pence’s attempt to expand “school choice” a potential disaster? As a long-time teacher and principal in public and nonpublic schools, I see both sides of the question, but I am apprehensive. Nonpublic schools help many elementary students, but that does not make them better than public schools. Nonpublic secondary schools prepare their students very well — if those students want to go to a traditional four-year college. They can seldom adequately prepare them for vocational and technical careers. Could our self-professed moderate leader be leading us in the wrong direction? You bet!

We may be moving too fast to evaluate school choice. We need a longitudinal study comparing the academic achievement of public and nonpublic school students. Doing that properly takes 10 to 12 years — too long to help today’s kids to take advantage of tomorrow’s opportunities. Even then, our ability to compare public and nonpublic schools would be limited.

Most nonpublic schools are religious schools. I was a Catholic school kid from first grade through high school. I later spent 15 years as a Catholic school teacher and principal. I was blessed to know and respect talented nonpublic school educators from many Christian faiths. We had different religious beliefs, but we all wanted our students to live and learn in a thoroughly Christian environment. One of my colleagues, who was principal of a Lutheran school, said, “I don’t even like to talk about secular subjects. We try to teach every subject from a Christian perspective.”

Our faith defines us. It is the fundamental difference between Christian schools and public schools. Parents of prospective students must accept that difference. Once, I responded to an article that claimed public schools did a better job than Christian schools. I replied that Christian schools don’t claim to do a better job. They do a different job. Originally, our public schools were also religious. Their nonsectarian character emerged later.

In 1647, the Puritans enacted the Old Deluder Law. They believed that reading the Bible helped Christians identify the deceptions of Satan, “the Old Deluder.” The law required communities to have teachers and schools. It provided a precedent for other colonies and territories. In 1852, our Indiana General Assembly called for a tax-supported public school system, although years passed before it was fully implemented.

How quickly and extensively should we change an institution that has taken our Hoosier predecessors a century and a half to create? Many problems have yet to be addressed. A few of them follow.

Filling vacant seats by lottery does offer equal access, but it doesn’t add even one more seat to any classroom. How does a school determine the number of vacant seats? I taught in one school district that used portable classrooms to handle growing enrollment. May out-of-district transfer students occupy empty seats in those rooms?

Portables usually provide temporary space while building permanent space. What happens to the transfer students when the construction is complete and the portables are no longer needed? Are they sent back to their home school districts or must the new construction have enough space for them, too? Voucher dollars pay for instruction but not construction. That comes from the school corporation’s building fund. How many Hoosier taxpayers want to pay higher taxes to build space for nonresident students?

Allowing students to attend nonpublic and out-of-district schools ignores the real problem. Moving kids around sometimes helps, but it does nothing to improve ineffective public schools. Hoosiers have demanded better schools for decades, but the politicians and bureaucrats in Indianapolis are content with the same old response: more standardized tests!

So what! We were doing that in 1968, when I began teaching. Since then, we have collected mountains of data that we haven’t used. The only new elements are performance-based incentives and penalties for public schools and teachers. We’re giving more money to schools and teachers that are already doing well and taking it away from those that are struggling and need it the most. Is that an example of good old-fashioned Hoosier common sense?

Moving money is no more effective than moving students. We won’t see significant improvements until we use our test data to develop newer, more creative ways to teach. However, the data do confirm what we already knew: Lower pupil-teacher ratios improve student performance. Will packing more kids into high performing schools increase their pupil-teacher ratios and decrease performance? Absolutely!

Despite evidence to the contrary, I still hope that Gov. Pence takes a more moderate approach to education than his predecessor did. We expelled Satan, the Old Deluder, from Indiana public schools generations ago. Our new governor needn’t become a New Deluder to take his place!

Mark Heinig Jr. of Kokomo is a retired Indiana teacher and principal. Contact him at markjr1708@gmail.com.     

Text Only | Photo Reprints
  • Vasicek: Celebrating Easter I have shared a few bits of Easter humor over the years, so I thought I’d start with a new one. Joseph of Arimathea was the wealthy Pharisee who is famous for helping to bury the body of Jesus. He procured the body, asking Pilate’s permission, and, w

    April 20, 2014

  • DAY: God trusted us with them Well, you heard about my wife and I, and our families from the past, so it is time for me to tell you about two of the prettiest girls I have ever known. They are our daughters Debbie and Patty. They are the greatest gifts from God that we have had i

    April 19, 2014

  • LoBianco: Bigger ethics questions raised in House Turner review

    Members of the House Ethics Committee who will take up Rep. Eric Turner’s case face daunting tasks as they try to answer two questions: Did their powerful colleague violate any ethics rules in privately lobbying against a measure that would have hurt his family’s business?

    April 18, 2014

  • Hicks: Measuring the unmeasurable

    One aspect of economic research I think is especially powerful is the ability to measure or monetize the things that humans clearly value but for which a market price is not necessarily apparent. This is one of the aspects of economic analysis that gives it such dominance over other social sciences.

    April 17, 2014

  • Rob Burgess House of Burgess: Bush presents 'The Art of Leadership'

    On April 5, “The Art of Leadership: A President’s Personal Diplomacy,” opened at the George W. Bush Presidential Library and Museum on the campus of Southern Methodist University. The display, which runs through June 3, boasts “portraits of more than two dozen world leaders” painted by Bush, according to the official literature.

    April 16, 2014 1 Photo

  • Bohanon: ‘Economics is fun’ in Vegas or in Bible study

    I am writing this on an airplane to Las Vegas. I’ll be attending the annual conference of the Association of Private Enterprise Education along with two of my colleagues and six of my students.

    April 16, 2014

  • Hayden: Want better teacher ratings? Ask the kids

    The state may be back where it started, encumbered with a flawed teacher grading system, a year after implementing what were meant to be tough new standards.
    That was the general consensus of the State Board of Education days after teacher evaluation data were released last week.

    April 15, 2014

  • BRIAN HOWEY: Mike Pence for president in 2016? Stay tuned Mike Pence for president? The swirl of 2016 national ticket talk surrounding Gov. Pence intensified over the past few weeks. I sat down with the governor in his office on Tuesday to find out what he's really thinking. A few hours prior, the Weekly S

    April 14, 2014

  • DICK WOLFSIE: Such a thing as too much My wife and I went on a binge last week. If you think I'm talking about an eating binge, you've never seen how thin we both are. If you think I mean a shopping binge, you don't know how cheap we are. And if you think it was a cleaning binge, you've n

    April 14, 2014

  • ED VASICEK: Chewing over news in bite-size vignettes Today, I am going to share a few "opinionettes" about current news items. Ready? Let's go! City prosperity The unemployment rate in the United States is down to 6.7 percent. This is its lowest level since October 2008. When I remember government effo

    April 13, 2014

Latest news
Featured Ads
Only on our website
AP Video
Raw: More Than 100,000 Gather for Easter Sunday Raw: Greeks Celebrate Easter With "Rocket War" Police Question Captain, Crew on Ferry Disaster Raw: Orthodox Christians Observe Easter Rite Ceremony Marks 19th Anniversary of OKC Bombing Raw: Four French Journalists Freed From Syria Raw: Massive 7.2 Earthquake Rocks Mexico Captain of Sunken SKorean Ferry Arrested Raw: Fire Destroys 3 N.J. Beachfront Homes Raw: Pope Presides Over Good Friday Mass Raw: Space X Launches to Space Station Superheroes Descend on Capitol Mall Man Charged in Kansas City Highway Shootings Obama Awards Navy Football Trophy Anti-semitic Leaflets Posted in Eastern Ukraine Raw: Magnitude-7.2 Earthquake Shakes Mexico City Ceremony at MIT Remembers One of Boston's Finest Raw: Students Hurt in Colo. School Bus Crash Deadly Avalanche Sweeps Slopes of Mount Everest

Click HERE to read all your Parade favorites including Hollywood Wire, Celebrity interviews and photo galleries, Food recipes and cooking tips, Games and lots more.
Kelly Lafferty's video on Tom Miller