Should our leaders take political stances?
In the Indiana higher education community, a world meant to promote free thinking and debate, a seemingly lower-level question of how university officials weigh in on hot-button issues is being pondered.
Indiana University President Michael McRobbie took the unusual step last week of throwing IU’s official support behind an effort to keep the state’s ban on gay marriage out of the constitution.
“Equality, compassion and respect for individuals have long been the bedrock of Indiana University’s educational mission, and the lack of tolerance implicit in HJR 6 (the amendment) runs counters to IU’s deeply held values,” McRobbie said in a statement announcing the university’s stance.
Business leaders, lawmakers, veteran activists and many other people and organizations have been taking sides in the upcoming gay marriage battle. Supporters of amending the ban into the constitution say it is needed to prevent the courts from effectively legalizing gay marriage in Indiana, but opponents say the step would enshrine inequality in the state.
But the involvement of Indiana’s higher education community is still somewhat unusual. Purdue University President Mitch Daniels decided the state’s other flagship university would not be taking sides in the debate.
“Over the years, Purdue has traditionally declined to comment on social issues that have been contended in the public arena,” Purdue Vice President for Public Affairs Julie Griffith told the Lafayette Journal & Courier. “Any departure from this policy should be undertaken only after careful consultation with the university’s many and diverse stakeholders.”
Daniels drew attention to the role of leaders and politics last year when, as part of his high-profile selection as president, he announced that he would refrain from commenting on certain political issues. That vow, offered in the middle of the 2012 election cycle as he was rounding out his term as governor, has led to questions of how it is applied.
Speaking last week at a Christian Science Monitor breakfast, Daniels offered his thoughts on everything from the Keystone XL pipeline to New Jersey Gov. Chris Christie, who won re-election Tuesday. But he also said his “vow of political celibacy” would keep him from weighing in on certain issues, like Virginia Attorney General Ken Cucinelli’s race for governor.
“Partisan means just that — Republican versus Democrat. The president has not participated in campaign politics of any kind. He sat out the 2012 election completely and has turned down every invitation from any partisan committee or candidate,” Purdue spokeswoman Shelley Triol told The Associated Press in an email responding to questions of how Daniels applies his vow.
Peter Wood, president of the conservative National Association of Scholars, has consistently defended Daniels in higher education forums and argues his voice is needed most in traditionally left-leaning academia. Wood wrote last month that Daniels was wrong to apologize for a paid appearance at a conservative Minnesota think tank and should not shy from public debate, despite Daniels’ political vow.
He noted that other university presidents, like Harvard’s Drew Faust and Spelman’s Beverly Tatum, have not shied from appearances at liberal think tanks like the Center for American Progress.
“Such ideological lockstep isn’t good for higher education,” he wrote last month on The Chronicle of Higher Education website. “It conveys to students that the range of views that can be openly discussed on campuses is limited. It drives faculty members underground. And it tells the public pretty vividly that colleges and universities are not the havens for open-minded inquiry that they pretend to be.”
Open commentary is hardly the same as throwing a university’s name behind a political stance, but McRobbie’s decision last week elevated the question of involvement for at least the duration of the gay marriage battle.
Tom LoBianco covers Indiana politics for The Associated Press. Follow him on Twitter @tomlobianco.
Should our leaders take political stances?
- BRIAN HOWEY: Sen. Mike Delph's re-election isn't foregone conclusion Mike Delph is a Repub lican state senator from Carmel, but he is well-known to Republicans throughout the state. The evangelical conservative ran for secretary of state in 2002, losing at the Republican convention. Three years later, he won a caucus
- DICK WOLFSIE: No life without the wife If my column isn't particu larly funny this week, I have no one to blame but my wife. I have always depended on Mary Ellen to in some way annoy, befuddle, confound or mock me, thus leading me to my inevitable outburst: "That's my next column." Mary E
- ED VASICEK: Cutting back sleep has unhealthy side effects There are certain interests we all have in common. One of them is food, a subject that excites me since I love to cook and I love to eat! But another area we have in common is sleep. Sleep is a natural function necessary to good health and solid thin
- MICHAEL HICKS: Wage debate is complex Two weeks ago the Congres sional Budget Office released a study on a proposed minimum wage hike. Its conclu sion was that raising the mini mum wage by 39 percent from $7.25 to $10.10 would reduce employment by roughly 500,000 jobs. I appreciated this
- RAY DAY: Choices we make in life As we grow older, we look back to how we got where we are and how circum stances prepared us for tomor row. There are choices that we all make that determine whether our lives will bring us happiness or sorrow. At the time we make those choices, we f
- MARK HEINIG: Will 'virtual schools' enrich or replace traditional education? When Hoo siers my age recall the school consolida tion struggle of the mid-20th century, we could say, "Been there, done that!" Until recently, I considered that battle finished. Maybe the interest in school consolidation is reviving. Does school co
House of Burgess: Like déjà vu all over again
A historic photo seared into my brain at an early age came back to me this week. It was taken May 28, 1963, in Jackson, Miss., by photographer Fred Blackwell of The Jackson Daily News. “Those are the bravest people I’ve ever seen in my life,” Blackwell told The Associated Press on June 2, 2013. “What they went through ... pictures don’t tell the story.”
- TOM LoBIANCO: Money pledge exposed in Indiana gay marriage fight A former Repub li can Party chairman's pledge to provide campaign cash to protect House members who were considering voting against a constitu tional gay marriage ban offers a rare look at the private power game that plays out on tough issues at the
- MAUREEN HAYDEN: Lugar's legacy: Cooperation to save the world In October 2012, at a dinner with friends, I found myself sitting next to woman who'd grown up in Russia. Finding out I was a reporter, she demanded to know why Indiana Republicans had months earlier cast aside longtime U.S. Sen. Richard Lugar. She c
- BILL STANCZYKIEWICZ: Poverty, inequality and opportunity in the Hoosier State New national research reveals America is still a land of opportunity, but many Indiana communities rank poorly in fostering upward economic mobility for children and youth. According to Harvard University's Equality of Opportunity Project, despite a
- More Columns Headlines