Kokomo Tribune; Kokomo, Indiana

Local News

December 18, 2012

Local case overturned on appeal

Ruling could affect domestic violence cases.

An Indiana Court of Appeals ruling on a Kokomo case could have a lasting impact on domestic violence victims who file for protective orders.

At stake is the ability of police to arrest abuse victims who invite their abusers to violate a protective order.

Last week the appeals court, in a split decision, overturned the conviction of Kokomo resident Melissa Patterson on two charges of aiding, inducing or causing invasion of privacy.

For the majority, Appeals Court Judge Ezra Friedlander said the Indiana General Assembly never intended make it a criminal offense to invite an abusive ex to violate a protective order.

The point of law covered by the case is a familiar one to local police — someone obtains a protective order against a partner, only to be found later voluntarily in the company of the same person.

If the protective order is still in effect, police usually arrest both individuals.

The Dec. 14 appeals court decision, written “for publication,” in order to serve as a legal precedent, contends only the subject of the protective order can and should be arrested under those circumstances.

A Howard County sheriff deputy arrested Patterson in October 2011, accusing her of helping her on-again, off-again boyfriend, Gregory Darden, violate the protective order she’d taken out against him.

Specifically, the deputy found Darden at the same house with Patterson, who in turn told the deputy she was “just visiting” Darden.

Both Darden and Patterson told the deputy they thought the protective order against Darden had been dismissed by the court, but the deputy arrested them anyway — Darden on a charge of invasion of privacy and Patterson on a charge of aiding, inducing or causing invasion of privacy.

About a month later, Darden and Patterson were both arrested again, for the same offenses.

Patterson sought to have the charges against her thrown out prior to trial, but Howard Superior Court 1 Judge William Menges declined her motion, based on the rationale that Patterson was criminally complicit in helping Darden violate the no-contact order.

The appeals court disagreed, basing its decision in part on a 2003 Ohio Supreme Court decision, State vs. Lucas.

In that decision, the appeals court noted Ohio’s protective order law is very similar to Indiana’s, and said Ohio’s law specifically states that even if the person who sought a protective order urges the person named in the order to violate it, that doesn’t nullify the power of the order.

In other words, even if Patterson asked Darden to visit her, that didn’t absolve Darden from criminal liability for violating the order.

Any criminal responsibility for violating the order would rest on the person named in the order — and not on the person who asked for the order, the appeals court concluded.

The Legislature’s decision to not write a specific criminal violation for urging someone to violate an order “must be viewed not as an omission, but as a determination that such should not be criminalized,” Friedlander wrote for the 2-1 majority.

In the Lucas decision, the Ohio Supreme Court also stated that “if petitioners for protective orders were liable for criminal prosecution, a violator of a protection order could create a real chill on the reporting of a violation by simply claiming the illegal visit was the result of an illegal invitation.”

“Protection orders are about the behavior of the [person named in the order] and nothing else,” the Ohio majority wrote. “How or why [that person] finds himself at the petitioner’s doorstep is irrelevant.”

Scott Smith can be reached at 765-454-8569 or at scott.smith@kokomotribune.com

Text Only | Photo Reprints
Local News
  • iRead program 03 Indiana improves overall rank on national child well-being report More Indiana parents are earning at least a high school diploma and their children are performing better in school too, but the advances in education still are not enough to counteract the lingering effects of the 2007 recession and lift families out

    July 22, 2014 2 Photos

  • NWS - KT072214 - IUK chancellor Sagamore Wabash WEB PIC - MS IUK Chancellor Sciame-Giesecke receives Sagamore of the Wabash Indiana University Kokomo Chancellor Susan Sciame-Giesecke received the state’s highest recognition on Saturday when she was honored with the prestigious Sagamore of the Wabash, presented by State Sen. Jim Buck.The presentation, on behalf of Gov. Mik

    July 22, 2014 1 Photo

  • Howard County jail to undergo improvements The Howard County Jail will be seeing some exterior renovations in the coming months.Howard County Commissioners approved $89,151 in improvements to the jail during their regular meeting Monday.The improvements include a parking lot resurfacing for $

    July 22, 2014

  • City agrees to allow billboard company to fix six structures Six more billboards will be put back up after the city reached a settlement with Burkhart Advertising. The agreement will allow Burkhart to repair and put back up six of the 11 billboards it owns that were damaged by tornadoes on Nov. 17. Five other

    July 21, 2014

  • Bonuses distributed to Howard County employees Employee bonuses were distributed for the third consecutive year for Howard County employees. The bonuses, which were approved during budgeting sessions in September, allowed full-time employees to receive $1,000, while part-time employees received $

    July 21, 2014

  • Indiana's bills for highway damage face challenge INDIANAPOLIS (AP) — A trucking company is asking the state appeals court to limit the Indiana Department of Transportation's authority to sue over damage done to state highways. The challenge is in court as the highway agency is trying to collect mor

    July 21, 2014

  • Indiana aligns livestock ID with federal program INDIANAPOLIS (AP) — The state Board of Animal Health has voted to adopt standards that align Indiana with a federal livestock identification program aimed at helping agriculture officials quickly track livestock in cases of disease. Indiana State Vet

    July 21, 2014

  • Haskett, Bella mugshot Team raising funds for Walk and Roll for Spina Bifida TIPTON — Much like other 5-year-olds, Izzabella “Bella” Haskett has many interests. She loves spending time with family and friends. She’s very inquisitive, and as her grandmother Sherri Haskett tells it, “talks a mile a minute.”Enjoying the outdoors

    July 21, 2014 1 Photo

  • Fair results

    ElectricGrand Champion, Zachary A. JohnsonReserve Grand Champion, Kelsey L. MontgomeryChampions — Braxten M. Barlow, Division 3 Electric Award - desktop calculator; Caleb Dockery, Division 1 Electric Award- notebook; Zachary A. Johnson, Advanced Divi

    July 21, 2014

  • Cow judging North Miami FFA team competes in international show DENVER — What’s the difference between an American cow and an English cow?No, it’s not the setup to a bad joke.It’s actually a pretty serious question for the six teens who make up the FFA dairy judging team at North Miami High School near Denver, In

    July 21, 2014 3 Photos

Latest news
Featured Ads
Only on our website
AP Video
Raw: Israel Bombs Multiple Targets in Gaza Veteran Creates Job During High Unemployment Raw: Cargo Craft Undocks From Space Station Widow: Jury Sent Big Tobacco a $23B Message New Orleans Plans to Recycle Cigarette Butts UN Security Council Calls for MH 17 Crash Probe Obama Bestows Medal of Honor on NH Veteran Texas Sending National Guard Troops to Border Hopkins to Pay $190M After Pelvic Exams Taped Foxx Cites Washington 'Circus Mirror' NASA Ceremony Honors Moon Walker Neil Armstrong Obama Voices Concern About Casualties in Mideast Diplomacy Intensifies Amid Mounting Gaza Toll AP Exclusive: American Beaten in Israel Speaks Obama Protects Gay, Transgender Workers Raw: Gaza Rescuers Search Rubble for Survivors Raw: International Team Inspects MH17 Bodies Raw: 25 Family Members Killed in Gaza Airstrike US Teen Beaten in Mideast Talks About Ordeal 'Weird Al' Is Wowed by Album's Success

Click HERE to read all your Parade favorites including Hollywood Wire, Celebrity interviews and photo galleries, Food recipes and cooking tips, Games and lots more.