Kokomo Tribune; Kokomo, Indiana

Opinion

January 25, 2013

Heinig Jr.: Teacher evaluations - Do they help or hurt?

Statehouse, leave decisions to schoolhouse

As an aging educator who put himself out to pasture five years ago, I still read news and editorials about our Indiana schools with great interest. On Jan. 13, the Kokomo Tribune published a lead story by Lindsey Ziliak: “Strapped for time:  Principals examining priorities to make time for teacher evaluations.” The story forced me to wrestle with an emotional conflict.

Because I was a principal for 10 years, I understand why every principal Ms. Ziliak interviewed stressed the advantages of our state’s new teacher evaluation process. I would have done the same thing. When a change is mandatory, a leader who dwells on the disadvantages accomplishes nothing! Nevertheless, most major changes have both advantages and disadvantages and the change in teacher evaluations is no exception.

Since I am no longer a principal, I am free to discuss both the advantages and disadvantages. The advantages attract more attention now, because implementation of the change is just beginning. The disadvantages will emerge later, when the change has become routine and its shortcomings slowly reveal themselves.

The classic format for teacher evaluation is pretty simple. It consists of setting goals, collecting data through observations and portfolios, assessing the data and developing an improvement plan. The improvement plan leads to a new set of goals and the quest for improvement continues, as it should!

Teacher evaluations do have inherent value. Every teacher can improve and should strive to do so. The participation of an external evaluator may help, but it’s not absolutely necessary. A well-trained teacher can do it alone. I can be the best evaluator in the world, but my recommendations are useless if the teacher doesn’t accept them. Only the teacher can implement the improvement plan. If that doesn’t happen, nothing else matters. As an external evaluator, I can contribute to the plan, but I can’t control it. Neither can the state. It merely regulates the process.

The state’s new regulations aren’t really so new. They offer more sound than substance. They focus on the peripheral characteristics of teacher evaluations: Who should evaluate and who should be evaluated? Which of a number of time-honored evaluation techniques should be used? How often should teachers be evaluated? This is the same old stuff done in the same old way. There is merely more pressure on the teacher and the principal.

Why are no research-based, creative new methods used to evaluate teachers? Could it be that no one is doing the kind of research that leads to originality and innovation? If nothing is new, we may be squandering the valuable time of teachers and principals.

Principals report a huge increase in the time needed for teacher evaluations. What other duties does this force them to neglect? I was a principal for 10 years. I usually worked about 60 hours a week at school, and I often took work home. I was not unique. Most principals I know work that many hours.

Some of them work even more. A few years ago, I applied for an assistant principal’s job at a high school in my home town. The principal telephoned to invite me to interview. When I arrived at the school, I was surprised to meet an old friend. The school secretary and I had been classmates from kindergarten through high school.

We spent a few minutes reminiscing while I waited for the principal to see me. I remarked that the principal must be very dedicated, since she had called me from home at 10 p.m. on a Sunday evening. My old friend smiled and said, “She was probably here at school. She frequently spends her Sunday evenings working in her office.”

I don’t know why that surprised me. Many principals use their weekends to do work that they can’t find time for during the week. I was one of them. Interruptions can easily consume much of the principal’s time on weekdays. That also explains why some principals work from home on days when they must attend meetings away from school. If they come to school first, they end up putting out fires (dealing with unexpected problems) and get to the meeting late or not at all!

I am certain many principals who are still working struggle with the same emotional conflict that vexes this old retired one: Should they spend their time complying with the state’s demands and risk their jobs, or spend it fulfilling needs of students, parents and teachers that may be more urgent. That’s a choice between local control and state control. It should be made at the schoolhouse door — not at the Statehouse door!  

Mark Heinig Jr. of Kokomo is a retired Indiana teacher and principal. Contact him at markjr1708@gmail.com.

1
Text Only | Photo Reprints
Opinion
  • Smoking ordinance misguided As a subscriber to the printed edition of the Kokomo Tribune, and a non-smoker, I was very interested upon seeing a page one article in the Aug. 13 edition titled “City-wide ban on smoking revealed.” After reading the article, my interest was peaked

    August 22, 2014

  • Why government openness matters Failing to share information makes us weaker. It enfeebles congressional oversight, which is a cornerstone of representative democracy and which, when aggressively carried out by fully informed legislators, can strengthen policy-making. One of the fu

    August 22, 2014

  • Aug. 22: Letters to the Editor Rokita wrong on GMOsThe Aug. 13 Tribune article about Rokita’s “Town Hall Meeting” left out a key issue — Rokita’s co-sponsorship of HR4432. This bill would ban mandatory labeling of currently genetically modified foods and prohibit any state from en

    August 22, 2014

  • Use the law to save lives As college students head back to campus, it’s a good time to remind them of the Indiana Lifeline Law.When the General Assembly passed the law two years ago, the goal was to encourage minors to call for help by giving them immunity from being prosecut

    August 22, 2014

  • It's time to deal with crisis For five and a half years, the president has gone around Congress to ignore, defy and alter laws in a variety of areas, from Obamacare implementation to issuing excessive new labor and environmental rules to infringing on religious freedom. It is no

    August 21, 2014

  • Nation must be united On Aug. 9, unarmed 18-year-old Michael Brown was shot at least six times, including twice in the head, by a police officer. Since that time, protestors and unrest have filled the streets of Ferguson, Missouri, a town near St. Louis.A similar scenario

    August 21, 2014

  • John understands fight against mental illness Terre Haute native Tommy John understands all too well how the pain of depression can lead a talented entertainer like Robin Williams to commit suicide.Like Williams, John achieved national fame, posting 288 victories as a major league baseball pitch

    August 21, 2014

  • Letters to the Editor Former Kokomoan on FergusonI was a resident of Kokomo from 1992 to 2008. Because of the housing crisis, my wife and I relocated to the St. Louis, Missouri area, which is close to where I grew up. With the eyes of the world focused upon the St. Louis

    August 21, 2014

  • OPN - KT082014 - king What Fergusonsays about us Aug. 9 is a day that Americans lost sight of themselves. It is the day Michael Brown, an 18-year-old black teenager of Ferguson, Mo., a suburb of St. Louis, was shot and killed by a white police officer, Darren Wilson. That evening, and for all but o

    August 20, 2014 1 Photo

  • Letters to the editor Congrats on wind farm defeat Congratulations to the citizens of Kokomo and Howard County! Your officials have done you a great favor by stopping any further considerations for construction of industrial wind turbines in your area. Now, if the fede

    August 20, 2014

Featured Ads
Only on our website
AP Video
Okla. Policeman Accused of Sex Assaults on Duty Raw: Egypt Bus Crash Kills at Least 33 Two Bodies Found in Adjacent Yards Dominican Republic Bans Miley Cyrus Concert Raw: Israeli Air Strike in Gaza Raw: Rescue Efforts Suspended at Japan Landslide Raw: Bodies of MH17 Victims Arrive in Malaysia Raw: Smaller Marches in Ferguson Marathon Suspect's Friend Pleads Guilty Attorney: Utah Eatery Had Other Chemical Burn Farm Resurgence Grows With Younger Crowd Microbrewery Chooses Special Can for Its Beer Ky. Firefighters Hurt in Ice Bucket Challenge Federal Investigation Will Look at Use of Force Community Deals With Michael Brown Aftermath US: We Do Not Pay Ransom to Terrorists Ferguson Teachers Training to Deal With Trauma Jon Hamm on the Unrest in Ferguson Tit for Tat? McDonald's Shuttered in Moscow Life on the Professional Video Game Circuit
Parade
Magazine

Click HERE to read all your Parade favorites including Hollywood Wire, Celebrity interviews and photo galleries, Food recipes and cooking tips, Games and lots more.
Obituaries
Poll