Transparency isn’t universally accepted in public entities.If it were, laws mandating transparency would be unnecessary.Last spring, the Indiana Legislature passed a law forcing the Indiana Economic Development Corp. to disclose the actual number of jobs its initiatives create, the number of jobs expected, tax credits distributed, and investments by firms receiving tax incentives. Despite receiving more than $100 million annually in tax funds, according to the Indiana Economic Digest, the IEDC hid detailed job-creation results from the public.“The public should be able to expect transparency from private companies when they receive public incentives,” said state Sen. Mike Delph, the Carmel Republican who authored the law.Transparency.Its definition seems clear in the case of the IEDC law — make public the tax incentives doled out, and the jobs expected and created, and hold recipients accountable for the jobs and investments promised. The word “transparency” comes up often in debates over various public policies and actions. It happened again this month with the release of a state-ordered review concerning grade changing by former superintendent of public instruction Tony Bennett last fall. Emails obtained by The Associated Press revealed Bennett and Department of Education staffers changed the A-to-F school ratings formula to boost an Indianapolis charter academy — considered a “quality control” benchmark school by Bennett — from a C to an A.The review, by the bipartisan duo of Bill Sheldrake and John Grew, concluded that Bennett applied the changes fairly, affecting numerous other schools. Their review did not address concerns that the charter, Christel House Academy, received attention because its founder is a prominent donor to Republican campaigns. Sheldrake and Grew did recommend a new, more thoroughly tested ratings system be developed and “based on transparency in all decision-making by the [Indiana State Board of Education] and [Indiana Department of Education] throughout the development process and final adoption of the revised rule.”In this case, what will transparency look like? The concept seems ironic, given that the grade-changing was uncovered through emails obtained by The AP. The Grew-Sheldrake report cited a rushed, flawed and misunderstood delivery of Indiana’s current A-to-F school ratings, and emphasized the need for a new, revised accountability system to be constructed openly, and publicly tested for a year, allowing feedback from schools.Calls for transparency aren’t limited to the IEDC law or the crafting of a better school ratings system. Similar calls are heard from Washington, D.C., to small-town public works boards.Hoosiers across the state could rightly apply those same expectations to any state and local officeholders and public boards. Do they practice “transparency in all decision-making,” as Sheldrake and Grew put it. Do the officials seek out and truly listen to divergent opinions, not just those of like-minded people? Do they update the public on a proposed project as it progresses?“What we sometimes get is the appearance of transparency, when the actual policy gets a certain amount of back-room negotiation,” said Anthony Fargo, vice president of the Indiana Coalition for Open Government and associate professor at the Indiana University School of Journalism.Professing support for transparency, open meetings and public-access laws is one thing for an officeholder or public board. Listening and including the public in the decision-making process is another. “You actually have to believe that you are obligated to listen to other people and consider what they’re saying,” Fargo said Friday by telephone from Bloomington.The word itself is loosely used.“I’m concerned about the using of ‘transparency’ as a buzzword,” said Andrew Downs, director of the Mike Downs Center for Indiana Politics in Fort Wayne. “Well, what do you mean by ‘transparency?’”It goes beyond the positive step of regularly posting public records and meeting minutes online. It may mean releasing budget numbers or spending records an officeholder would rather keep out of the headlines. It may involve scheduling a series of hearings on an issue, in which average people make comments, not just policymakers. Such extensive give-and-take may be wearisome to a lawmaker or board member, but it’s necessary.“Governing is exhausting, and doing it transparently is probably even more so,” Fargo said. “But doing it that way is the bedrock on which our society is built.”Mark Bennett writes for the (Terre Haute) Tribune-Star.
It also includes sincerely listening to the people
- Locals won't wait for state Educators at Indiana University just two weeks before classes began in 2006 reported public schools should begin instruction earlier than kindergarten. A statewide preschool program was needed to ensure Hoosier students succeed in college and at work
- MARK HEINIG: Will 'virtual schools' enrich or replace traditional education? When Hoo siers my age recall the school consolida tion struggle of the mid-20th century, we could say, "Been there, done that!" Until recently, I considered that battle finished. Maybe the interest in school consolidation is reviving. Does school co
- March 7, 2014: Letters to the editor Draft standards: wolf in sheep's clothing 2014 started with great optimism for thousands of concerned parents, grandparents and many educators from around the state. The governor spoke of his support for "uncommonly high standards written by Hoosiers
- Students must be helped Despite the good efforts of those who supported Common Core educational standards for Indiana schools, the Indiana Legislature has shut the door on the new standards adopted by most states. Instead, Indiana will be adopting its own homegrown school s
- Take city up on its offer It was about 2 a.m. when the tornado touched down in Henderson County, Ky., Nov. 6, 2005. The twister crossed the Ohio River and churned into a mobile-home community near Evansville, picking up some of the trailers and pitching them into a nearby pon
House of Burgess: Like déjà vu all over again
A historic photo seared into my brain at an early age came back to me this week. It was taken May 28, 1963, in Jackson, Miss., by photographer Fred Blackwell of The Jackson Daily News. “Those are the bravest people I’ve ever seen in my life,” Blackwell told The Associated Press on June 2, 2013. “What they went through ... pictures don’t tell the story.”
- March 5, 2014: Letters to the editor Senate bill is harmful to God's creation The Indiana House of Representatives amended Senate Bill 340 last week to obliterate a statewide energy efficiency program, known as Energizing Indiana. Still in its infancy, this successful program has alread
- TOM LoBIANCO: Money pledge exposed in Indiana gay marriage fight A former Repub li can Party chairman's pledge to provide campaign cash to protect House members who were considering voting against a constitu tional gay marriage ban offers a rare look at the private power game that plays out on tough issues at the
- Words can discourage development Kokomo Mayor Greg Goodnight, incensed some Howard County Republicans won't stop badmouthing the city's dealings with developer Jeff Broughton, took a jab at Howard County Republican Party chairman Craig Dunn in his State of the City speech last week.
- Prepared for a disaster? Even before we closed the book last May on our five-week series of disaster preparedness, headlines came pouring in about tornadoes ripping through Texas and Oklahoma. And the season was just getting started. Bulldozers used to clear the way for resc
- More Opinion Headlines